best places to eat in islamorada

best places to eat in islamorada

Finding the right restaurant in Islamorada can be difficult. There’s so much to choose from, and the options aren’t always accurate. It’s important to find a great place if you want to enjoy your food while eating at a table! To make that easier, read on for some of the best places to eat in islamorada!. If you’re looking for the best places to eat in Islamorada, FL, you have found the right place. In this article, we’ll help you find the most delicious and unique spots in the area. You will learn about five different eating establishments that are worth a visit!

The best places to eat in Islamorada are as varied as the island itself. Some of your best bets include the Barefoot Bar & Grill, where you can get a delicious burger and fries with a tropical twist on the side; or The Beach House Cafe, where you can enjoy some sweet treats while taking in the laid-back atmosphere.

If you’re looking for something more adventurous, try out the nearby Curio’s Bistro & Wine Bar. It has an eclectic menu that includes everything from roasted duck breast to shrimp tacos, but if you’re not sure where to start, their “Create Your Own” option is a great way to get creative with your choice of entrée.

If you want to check out some local art while you’re there, be sure to visit Art Boutiki on Main Street! Their gallery features paintings and sculptures by local artists at very affordable prices—and if any of the artists happen to be there in person, they’ll happily pose for photos with their work!

If you’re looking for a great place to eat in Islamorada, look no further than [restaurant name]. Here at [restaurant name], we pride ourselves on being able to provide guests with the best dining experience possible. We are committed to providing our guests with fresh ingredients and a variety of options, so that each time you visit us, you can expect something new and exciting.

Our menu includes items such as:

  • Steakhouse Steaks: Filet Mignon, New York Strip, Ribeye, Tenderloin
  • Seafood: Oysters on the Half Shell, Shrimp Cocktail, Lobster Tail
  • Pasta & Pizza: Ravioli Stuffed with Spinach & White Truffle Cream Sauce or Chicken Marsala Orzo Pasta with Cajun Shrimp & Mushrooms; Baked Lasagna; Fresh Mozzarella Cheese Stuffed Pizza Margherita; Baked Ziti with Meatball Ricotta Filling; Pepperoni Pizza; Meatball Subs; Italian Sausage Subs

best restaurants in islamorada on the water

1. Lorelei Restaurant and Cabana Bar (mm 82)

The Lorelei, perhaps the most famous of any Islamorada establishment, remains the place to go for a waterfront sunset celebration complete with cocktails.

Sunset dining with classic local seafood dishes occurs nightly, but the bigger emphasis seems to be on happy hour-energized crowds. Both live music and local magician shows entertain tourists, but the highlight of any evening here is when everyone toasts the sunset to celebrate another day in the islands.

Not up for cocktails? The Lorelei also offers a brunch. Enjoy the same water views with a surprising morning zen at this nightly party place. A cup of coffee and a delicious order of shrimp and grits here is a great start to any day in the Florida Keys.

The fish tacos, cracked conch, wings, and key lime pie are all mouthwatering.

2. The Square Grouper Islamorada (mm 80)

A relative newcomer to Islamorada expanding up from its original location in the lower keys, this “dinner-only” restaurant offers delicious food with a creative cocktail list. The bartenders show pride in making a proper crafted cocktail and their efforts are applauded by the patrons. Located on the end of a canal on the water, it provides both outdoor and indoor dining and has quickly becoming a must-go place in Islamorada.

3. The Shrimp Shack (mm 82)

When the Shrimp Shack owner decided to re-open a restaurant locally, she looked around to identify types of cuisine that weren’t being serviced in the community, and decided to focus on the local Key West Pink Shrimp. After re-opening, it did not take long for the Food Network to come knocking and film an episode of Guy Fieri’s Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives.

4. Lazy Days (mm 80)

Another location offering the popular, “You Hook, We Cook” is Lazy Days. A seaside restaurant found on the Atlantic Ocean side may not offer sunset views, but it still offers picturesque views of the crystal clear waters of the Florida Keys. Whether you select beachside tables or want the second level terrace, here a menu complete with locally caught fish can be prepared many ways — including the iconic Lazy Days style.

best lunch islamorada


Chef Michael’s is known for elegant dining in a casual island setting. The menu features upscale fish and modern American dishes and is known to have the best variety of freshly caught fish in Islamorada. Chef Michael Ledwith, the restaurant’s namesake chef-owner, got his start in some of New York’s best restaurants. He eventually made his way down to the Caribbean where he learned the art of cooking seafood. He created a name for himself in Central Florida but the island life called him to The Keys and his restaurant is known as one of the best in the Upper Keys. Try the hogfish, the catch of the day, or join Chef Michael for his legendary Sunday brunch.


If you are just driving through Islamorada and can’t stay for long, my favorite lunch spot is The Green Turtle Inn. An Islamorada icon, the Green Turtle Inn has been a local favorite since 1947. You may recognize it from its appearance on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives on the Food Network. I like ‘the Turtle’ for its authentic Keys cooking and nostalgic old-Florida feeling. The laid back diner is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and you’ll find Florida Keys specialties and southern staples on the menu. I recommend the burger and the desserts are fantastic.

Morada Bay Beach Cafe is an outdoor Mediterranean cafe set in the sand. You’ll follow a tropical flower lined path and then walk through the sand to get to your table, which is set overlooking blue waters and palm trees. This is the perfect place to start your vacation and get into relaxation mode. If you’re staying awhile, enjoy the cocktails, frozen drinks, and extensive wine list. If it’s just a short road trip stop, you can enjoy the island-inspired menu featuring local seafood and produce.

Leave a Comment